Abstract
This ethnographic article provides an insight into the current state of Jyotish, or Vedic astrology, with a focus on the prevalent patriarchal and hierarchical systems within the astrological community. The study examines the enduring influence of the Hindu caste system on the profession, particularly as it restricts women’s participation in Jyotish while perpetuating a culture of passive aggression and hierarchical oppression. Through ethnographic observations, interviews, and analysis, the article sheds light on the entrenched sexism and class-based structures that hinder the growth and diversification of the Jyotish community. The research was conducted between 2012-2023.
Introduction
As I have an ethnographic background, I decided to apply the skills I learned in ethnomusicology and study the culture of Jyotish. Vedic astrology, or Jyotish, an ancient tradition deeply rooted in Hindu astrology, has persisted as a respected practice with enduring reverence for its connections to spiritual, cultural, and personal realms. However, the profession is grappling with the remnants of the old patriarchal and hierarchical systems, which continue to limit the involvement of women and perpetuate oppressive class dynamics. This ethnographic study seeks to explore and bring to light the complexities of the contemporary Jyotish community, particularly focusing on the astrologers themselves, as they navigate these inherited structures.
What is Ethnography?
Ethnography is a research methodology that involves the systematic study and documentation of human cultures and societies. It typically involves immersing oneself in the community or culture being studied, engaging in prolonged fieldwork, and observing and participating in the daily life and practices of the community members. Ethnographers often use a combination of qualitative research methods, such as participant observation, interviews, and analysis of cultural artifacts, to gain an in-depth understanding of the social and cultural phenomena within the studied group. The goal of ethnography is to provide a rich, holistic, and nuanced portrayal of a particular cultural context, shedding light on the beliefs, behaviors, and social structures of the people being studied.
Some ethnographic tropes to consider on the subject of traditional gender roles and Jyotish in India included in this article:
1. Ritual and Domesticity: Exploring the contrast between the ritualistic and scholarly nature of Jyotish practice and the traditional domestic roles assigned to women in Indian society.
2. Gendered Spaces: Investigating the physical and social spaces associated with Jyotish learning and practice, and how they may be gendered or segregated based on traditional norms.
3. Oral Tradition and Gender: Understanding the transmission of Jyotish knowledge through oral tradition and how gender dynamics may have influenced the transfer of knowledge and access to learning opportunities.
4. Community Expectations: Examining the roles of community, family, and societal expectations in shaping perceptions of gender roles and participation in Jyotish.
5. Changing Dynamics: Documenting and analyzing instances of shifts or modernization in gender roles and access to Jyotish education and practice, and the impact of such changes on traditional cultural norms and power structures.
What is Hinduism, the Vedas, and Jyotish?
Hinduism is one of the world’s oldest religions and is based on the belief in dharma, karma, and reincarnation. It comprises a diverse set of practices, beliefs, and rituals, and lacks a single founder or central religious authority. Hinduism emphasizes the pursuit of dharma (moral duty) and the four goals of life (dharma, artha, kama, and moksha). It has a rich tradition of sacred texts that include the Vedas, Upanishads, Puranas, and epics like the Ramayana and Mahabharata. The Vedas are ancient scriptures of Hinduism and are considered to be the oldest texts of Hindu philosophy. There are four Vedas—Rigveda, Samaveda, Yajurveda, and Atharvaveda—and they contain hymns, rituals, and spiritual knowledge that form the basis of Hindu religious practices.
Jyotish, also known as Vedic astrology, is an ancient system of astrology that originated in India. It is based on the movement of celestial bodies and their influence on human lives. Jyotish uses the position of planets and stars at the time of an individual’s birth to map out their life and make predictions about their future. Practitioners of Jyotish study the positions of celestial bodies in relation to a person’s birth chart to determine their strengths, weaknesses, and potential life events. Jyotish plays a significant role in Hindu culture and is often consulted for making important life decisions, such as marriage, career, and financial matters. While Jyotish can provide individuals with insights and guidance, it is also subject to debate and skepticism, with critics questioning its scientific validity and accuracy.
Jyotish, often called the “Science of Light,” is deeply rooted in the ancient Vedic tradition and is considered the “eyes of the Vedas.” It is a system of astrology that has been passed down through generations, offering insights into an individual’s destiny and the cosmic forces that shape their lives. Jyotish is not just a tool for predicting the future, but a complex and profound science that encompasses astronomy, mathematics, and philosophy. It illuminates the interconnectedness of all things and offers a holistic understanding of the universe. With its rich history and spiritual significance, Jyotish continues to be a guiding light for those seeking a deeper understanding of themselves and the world around them.
The Brihat Parashara Hora Sastra
Jyotish is rooted in ancient Indian scriptures and traditions, with the foundational principles being based on the Brihat Parashara Hora Sastra. This text, attributed to the sage Parashara, is considered one of the most authoritative and comprehensive works on astrology in Hindu culture. Parashara is revered as the father of Vedic astrology, and his teachings have significantly influenced the development and practice of Jyotish. He is credited with laying down the essential concepts, techniques, and principles of Vedic astrology, providing a framework for understanding celestial influences on human life. Parashara’s teachings encompass various aspects of astrology, including planetary movements, birth charts, and predictive techniques, and continue to form the basis of Jyotish practice today.
Learning Jyotish the Traditional Way in India
In India, traditional Jyotishis typically undergo a rigorous and immersive process of learning that often begins at a young age. Apprentice Jyotishis, or students, typically seek out a Guru (master) to study under and learn the intricacies of Jyotish. The teaching methodologies are often oral and experiential, with the Guru imparting knowledge through direct instruction, discussion, and demonstration. This traditional approach emphasizes a strong teacher-student relationship, with an emphasis on practical application, memorization of sacred texts, and observation of astrological phenomena. Students may spend years or even decades studying under their Guru, absorbing the wisdom and techniques passed down through generations. Additionally, students often engage in dedicated self-study, meditation, and practical application of Jyotish principles to deepen their understanding. This immersive and holistic approach to learning enables traditional Jyotishis in India to develop a profound understanding of astrology and its connected spiritual and cultural traditions.
Historically, the learning and practice of Jyotish in India has been predominantly male-dominated, with a limited representation of women in the field. This imbalance can be attributed to traditional societal and cultural norms, where certain knowledge and spiritual practices, including Jyotish, were often passed down through patriarchal lineages. Additionally, the restrictive gender roles and expectations placed on women in the past often limited their access to education and participation in scholarly or spiritual pursuits. However, it’s important to recognize that this is an evolving landscape, and there are increasing efforts to challenge and change these historical norms. Today, there are more opportunities for women to pursue Jyotish education and practice. It is crucial to break down these barriers and encourage inclusivity, ensuring that women have equal access to the teaching and practice of Jyotish. This inclusivity not only supports gender equality, but it also enriches the field of Jyotish by incorporating diverse perspectives and experiences.
Traditional Roles for Women in India
In traditional Indian society, particularly in the past, women were often expected to fulfill specific roles and responsibilities within the household, such as caregiving, managing the household, and maintaining familial and social connections. These roles were deeply rooted in cultural and societal norms, often shaping the expectations for women’s conduct and pursuits. Jyotish, as a scholarly and spiritual practice, was traditionally seen as incongruent with these prescribed female roles. The demanding nature of Jyotish education and practice, which often required prolonged periods of study, meditation, and participation in rituals, was perceived as conflicting with the traditional image of a woman’s duties within the household. As a result, women faced significant barriers in accessing Jyotish education and involvement in the practice. While these traditional views are shifting as societal norms evolve, the historical perception of incongruence between traditional female roles and participation in Jyotish continues to influence the representation of women in the field.
What is the Hindu Caste System?
The Hindu caste system is a social hierarchy that has been a traditional aspect of Hindu society for many centuries. It categorizes individuals into distinct social classes, or castes, with each caste carrying specific social status, rights, and responsibilities. The system is based on the belief that individuals are born into their castes based on their karma from past lives, and that each caste has its own duties and privileges. Traditionally, the caste system has four main varnas or broad social categories, including Brahmins (priests and scholars), Kshatriyas (warriors and rulers), Vaishyas (merchants and farmers), and Shudras (laborers and service providers). Below these varnas are the Dalits, or “untouchables,” who have historically been marginalized and relegated to the lowest social status. Although the Indian government has officially abolished discrimination based on caste, the system’s influence continues to permeate many aspects of Indian society.
The Hindu caste system has not been officially abolished. However, the Indian government has taken measures to address discrimination and promote equality among castes. The Constitution of India, which came into effect on January 26, 1950, established the country as a democratic republic and guaranteed fundamental rights to all citizens, regardless of caste or creed. Additionally, the government has implemented affirmative action programs, known as reservations, to provide opportunities for historically marginalized communities and lower castes. While these efforts have sought to mitigate the effects of the caste system, social and economic disparities persist, and the challenges of caste discrimination continue to be a significant aspect of Indian society.
The Hindu Caste System & Fascism
Fascism is a far-right, authoritarian political ideology characterized by dictatorial power, forcible suppression of opposition, strong nationalism, and often racism or xenophobia. It advocates for a centralized, autocratic government led by a totalitarian leader, and it seeks to create a strong, centralized national identity through the subjugation of individual rights and freedoms. Fascism often incorporates militarism, and it emphasizes aggressive foreign policy and the use of violence and coercion to maintain power and control. Throughout history, fascist regimes have been associated with mass propaganda, persecution of minorities, and the suppression of dissent.
The Indian caste system is inherently fascist as it enforces a rigid social hierarchy based on birth, which perpetuates systemic discrimination and oppression. With its origins deeply rooted in Hindu scriptures, the caste system categorizes individuals into fixed social groups, determining their roles, privileges, and opportunities in society. This rigid structure not only perpetuates social inequality but also dictates and restricts social interactions, economic opportunities, and access to education and resources. The caste system’s inherent discrimination leads to the marginalization and exclusion of certain groups, perpetuating deep-seated inequalities and injustices. Furthermore, the system’s emphasis on maintaining purity and hierarchy reinforces authoritarian control and fosters the subjugation of individuals, mirroring the traits of fascist regimes. The inherent oppressive nature of the caste system highlights its similarity to fascist ideologies, cementing its place as a deeply entrenched form of institutionalized oppression.
While it’s true that the Indian government officially abolished the caste system through legislation, its influence continues to persist through unofficial observance in contemporary society, particularly concerning marriage. Despite legal measures to promote equality and prohibit caste-based discrimination, many individuals still prioritize marrying within their own caste. This perpetuates the deeply entrenched social divisions and exclusionary practices associated with the caste system, as it reinforces traditional boundaries and hierarchies. The preference for intra-caste marriages reflects the enduring influence of caste-based identity and social expectations, highlighting the ongoing societal impact of a system that was officially abolished. This persistence underscores the complex and deeply ingrained nature of the caste system’s legacy, challenging efforts to fully eradicate its influence within Indian society.
The Hindu Caste System & Women
The Hindu caste system has historically been a patriarchal social structure that has held women back in various ways. Women in lower castes often face compounded discrimination based on both gender and caste. They have been subjected to oppression, limited educational and economic opportunities, and restricted social mobility. In many cases, women from lower castes have been particularly vulnerable to exploitation and violence.
Additionally, the caste system has also perpetuated harmful gender norms and practices, leading to the marginalization and subjugation of women. Patriarchal attitudes and practices within the caste system have restricted women’s autonomy, decision-making abilities, and freedom to pursue their goals and aspirations. The intersection of the gender and caste dynamics has resulted in a complex system of discrimination and oppression for women.
While there have been efforts to address these issues through legislation and social reforms, the deeply entrenched nature of the caste system has made it difficult to fully eradicate its negative impact on women’s lives.
The Patriarchal Stranglehold
The influence of the Hindu caste system on Jyotish is strikingly evident in the gender dynamics prevalent within the community. The tradition dictates that only men can assume the role of Jyotishis, enforcing a patriarchal stranglehold that restricts female participation. This exclusion greatly impacts the profession, depriving it of diverse perspectives and insights. The perpetuation of this patriarchal mindset obstructs the growth of Jyotish as a holistic and inclusive practice, and serves as a barrier to the empowerment of women within the astrological field.
In the context of Western clients seeking astrological guidance, there is a growing preference for female astrologers who are not Indian males. This may stem from a perception that some male Indian astrologers lack adequate psychological therapy skills for counseling, and may even engage in practices that are ethically concerning. For instance, some clients have reported instances of male astrologers making unsolicited and distressing predictions about their lifespans, causing emotional distress.
Additionally, there are accounts of clients being pressured into purchasing expensive upayas, which are traditional Jyotish remedies, such as raw gemstones, at prices that are financially burdensome. In response to these experiences, female Jyotishis are seen as offering a more empathetic and nurturing approach, with a focus on emotional support and ethical practices, aligning with the evolving needs of Western clients seeking astrological guidance.
Hierarchical Oppression and Intimidation
Furthermore, the class-based structure inherent in the system of Jyotish perpetuates a hierarchical environment that fosters passive aggression and intimidation, particularly in educational settings. Many teachers, who are often placed at the higher echelons of this structure, exhibit passive aggressive behavior towards their students, preventing them from realizing their potential as astrologers and perpetuating a culture of fear and subordination. The hierarchical dynamics impede the growth of aspiring astrologers and create a toxic learning environment that stymies creativity and collaboration.
In some instances, successful women in Jyotish may consciously or unconsciously perpetuate patriarchal norms by holding back and intimidating new women in the field. This behavior can stem from the systemic suppression and challenges they themselves have faced in a male-dominated domain. By replicating these power dynamics, they inadvertently perpetuate a toxic environment that hinders the progress of other women in Jyotish. It is crucial for this trait to change, as it not only perpetuates gender inequality but also undermines the growth and inclusivity of the Jyotish community. Encouraging collaboration, mentorship, and support among women in Jyotish can help break this cycle and create a more empowering and nurturing space for all practitioners, irrespective of gender.
The Culture of Divination
Divination is a practice that encompasses a variety of methods used to gain insight, guidance, or knowledge about present or future events. Commonly associated with spiritual or mystical traditions, divination techniques can include astrology, tarot card reading, pendulum dowsing, crystal ball gazing, and many others. The underlying belief is that through these practices, individuals can tap into spiritual or supernatural forces to obtain information that may be beyond their ordinary senses or reasoning. Divination is often used for personal growth, decision-making, and seeking understanding about various aspects of life, and while it is widely practiced, interpretations and beliefs about the accuracy and ethics of divination can vary greatly among cultures and religious traditions.
Culture can be defined as the learned behaviors and values that shape a particular group of people, and the world of divination, particularly astrology, has its own unique culture. In this culture, there is a strong emphasis on word-of-mouth referrals, as satisfied clients often refer others to their trusted astrologers. This network of referrals is an integral part of the divination culture, as it reflects a sense of trust and reliance on the expertise and insights of the astrologer. Additionally, the culture of astrology is built on the traditions, techniques, and symbolic systems that have been passed down through generations, creating a rich tapestry of knowledge and wisdom. Astrology’s culture also encompasses diverse perspectives and approaches, reflecting the unique blend of experiences and interpretations that enrich its practice.
In the culture of divination and astrology, the phenomenon of referrals extends beyond just clients seeking astrologers, but also encompasses students seeking knowledgeable and reputable teachers. Aspiring astrologers often rely on referrals from experienced practitioners or through word-of-mouth within the astrological community to find teachers who can impart the intricate knowledge and skills necessary for mastering the practice of astrology. This culture of referrals in teacher-student relationships underscores the value placed on mentorship, lineage, and the passing down of wisdom from one generation to the next. It also reinforces the importance of learning within a trusted, supportive environment that respects the traditions and principles of astrology.
In recent years, social media has become an integral part of the culture of divination, as practitioners and enthusiasts utilize platforms such as Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, and Facebook to share content, connect with like-minded individuals, and offer divination services. Social media provides a unique space for diviners to showcase their talents, offer readings, and build a community around their practice. It also allows for the dissemination of information, including tips, techniques, and interpretations, making divination more accessible to a broader audience. Additionally, social media has facilitated the creation of online divination courses, workshops, and events, enabling practitioners to connect with students and clients from around the world, ultimately shaping the way divination is learned, shared, and integrated into modern spiritual practices.
The historical lack of equal rights for women in India up until very recently has undoubtedly impacted their roles as students and teachers in astrology. Traditionally, women in India have faced significant societal barriers in accessing education and professional opportunities. In the context of astrology, this may have resulted in fewer women having the chance to pursue formal education and training in astrology, as well as limited opportunities to establish themselves as respected teachers and practitioners within the astrological community. However, as attitudes towards gender equality evolve, there is increasing recognition and support for women’s participation and leadership in the field of astrology. Efforts to promote inclusivity and empower women in astrology are essential for creating a more balanced and diverse representation of perspectives within this ancient practice.
Female Vedic astrologers experience both negative and positive aspects of social media content and networking. On the negative side, female astrologers may face a heightened focus on their physical appearance, leading to objectification and judgment that could overshadow their expertise. Additionally, they may encounter sexist comments, harassment, and gender-based discrimination within online communities. However, social media also provides a platform for female astrologers to challenge stereotypes, amplify their voices, and create supportive networks. They have the opportunity to reach a wider audience, share their knowledge, and inspire others. Through digital platforms, female Vedic astrologers can connect with fellow practitioners, offer mentorship, and establish themselves as influential figures in the field, ultimately contributing to the empowerment and visibility of women in astrology.
What is a Jyotish Reading?
A reading from a professional Vedic astrologer typically involves a thorough analysis of an individual’s birth chart, also known as a Janma Kundali. The astrologer will examine the positions of celestial bodies such as planets and stars at the time of the person’s birth, as well as the specific placements of these bodies in the various astrological houses. They will interpret the influence of these celestial configurations on the individual’s personality, relationships, career, health, and other aspects of life. Additionally, the astrologer may provide insights into future trends, potential life events, and guidance for making decisions based on the information gleaned from the birth chart. The reading may also involve the use of dashas (planetary periods) and transits to provide a comprehensive understanding of the individual’s past, present, and future. The aim of the reading is to offer guidance and perspective on various aspects of the client’s life based on the principles and techniques of Vedic astrology.
Vedic astrologers offer various types of readings based on specific areas of life and the needs of their clients. Some common types of readings include:
1. Natal Chart Reading: A comprehensive analysis of the individual’s birth chart, providing insights into their personality, strengths, weaknesses, and potential life paths.
2. Relationship Compatibility Reading: Examines the compatibility between individuals in romantic or business relationships based on their birth charts, helping to understand the dynamics and potential challenges in the relationship. In India, this is one of the most popular and important readings, placing emphasis upon “mangal dosha”, or how the partner’s Mars placements interact. According to certain rules, this can determine if an arranged marriage is viable or not.
3. Career and Financial Reading: Focuses on the individual’s career prospects, financial opportunities, and potential success based on astrological indicators in the birth chart.
4. Health and Wellness Reading: Provides insights into potential health challenges, predispositions, and recommendations for maintaining well-being based on astrological influences.
5. Annual Forecasts: Predictions and guidance for the upcoming year, including potential opportunities, challenges, and significant life events based on the planetary transits and dashas.
6. Muhurta (Auspicious Timing) Reading: Assists in finding the most favorable timing for important events such as weddings, starting a business, or other significant endeavors based on astrological principles.
7. Prashna (Question) Reading: Addresses specific questions or concerns posed by the client, providing astrological insights and guidance based on the time the question is asked.
These are just a few examples of the different types of readings that Vedic astrologers may offer, tailored to address specific aspects of life and the individual needs of their clients.
Main Differences Between Western & Vedic Astrology
The main differences between Western and Vedic astrology lie in their underlying philosophies, techniques, and interpretations. Here are some key distinctions:
1. Philosophical Foundations: Western astrology is based on the tropical zodiac, while Vedic astrology uses the sidereal zodiac. Additionally, Vedic astrology is deeply rooted in Hindu philosophy and cosmology, incorporating concepts such as karma, dharma, and reincarnation.
2. Zodiac System: The zodiac used in Western astrology is divided into twelve equal segments of 30 degrees each, starting from the vernal equinox. In contrast, Vedic astrology employs a sidereal zodiac based on the fixed positions of the stars, dividing the sky into 27 equal sections with varying lengths known as nakshatras.
3. Calculations and Techniques: Vedic astrology utilizes complex mathematical calculations and specific techniques such as dashas (planetary periods), yogas (combinations of planetary alignments), and divisional charts for detailed analysis. Western astrology also employs various techniques, but the emphasis is often on psychological insights and the interpretation of planetary aspects and transits.
4. Timing Systems: Vedic astrology places a strong emphasis on predictive techniques such as dashas, which are unique planetary periods that influence different stages of life. Western astrology also uses timing techniques, but they differ in their calculation and interpretation from those utilized in Vedic astrology.
5. Approach to Interpretation: Vedic astrologers typically take a holistic approach, combining astrological analyses with insights from Hindu scriptures, religious beliefs, and spiritual practices. Western astrologers may focus more on psychological and humanistic perspectives when interpreting astrology charts.
These differences reflect the distinct historical, cultural, and philosophical backgrounds of Western and Vedic astrology, leading to variations in their methodologies and interpretations.
Current Popularity of Jyotish
Jyotish has gained increased popularity in recent years, partly due to its association with Eastern spirituality, holistic traditions, and ancient wisdom. As interest in Eastern philosophies has grown globally, Jyotish has become more widely recognized for its holistic approach, which incorporates not only astrological insights but also elements of yoga, Ayurveda, and spiritual practices. Furthermore, the deep-rooted belief in karma, dharma, and the cyclical nature of time within Jyotish resonates with individuals seeking to understand their life’s purpose and receive guidance from a more spiritual perspective. Additionally, the intricate predictive techniques and timing systems of Jyotish, such as dashas and divisional charts, have also contributed to its appeal, as they provide detailed and specific insights into various life events and challenges. Overall, the increasing popularity of Jyotish compared to Western astrology can be attributed to its holistic approach, deep-rooted spiritual connections, and the timeless wisdom embedded in its teachings.
Definition of Cultural Appropriation & Orientalism
Cultural appropriation refers to the adoption of elements of a marginalized culture by members of a dominant culture, often without fully understanding or respecting the historical, religious, or cultural significance of those elements. Orientalism, as defined by Dr. Edward Said, is a term used to describe the way in which Western cultures historically have depicted and represented Eastern cultures as exotic, mysterious, and inferior, perpetuating stereotypes and power imbalances.
In the context of Jyotish, these concepts intersect as the practice of Vedic astrology has been influenced and at times commodified by Western cultures, and particularly Western astrologers, leading to forms of cultural appropriation and Orientalism. For example, there are instances where Jyotish has been divorced from its spiritual and cultural roots, with practitioners cherry-picking elements they find appealing while disregarding the broader philosophical context and cultural significance. This can lead to the distortion or oversimplification of Jyotish, reinforcing Orientalist stereotypes and misrepresentations and undermining the integrity of the practice. It is important for practitioners and enthusiasts of Jyotish to approach the tradition with cultural sensitivity, respect, and a deep understanding of its origins and significance.
Indeed, one does not have to be a Hindu to practice Jyotish, as the principles of Vedic astrology are based on astronomical and mathematical calculations that are not inherently tied to any specific religious belief. Jyotish, known as the “Science of Light,” is rooted in the idea that celestial bodies and their movements have a profound influence on earthly events and human lives. Its principles and techniques are based on observing and interpreting the positions of planetary bodies at the time of a person’s birth and the potential effects they may have. This empirical and systematic approach means that Jyotish can be practiced and utilized by individuals of any faith, as its effectiveness is not contingent on adherence to a particular religious tradition. This inclusivity allows people from diverse backgrounds and belief systems to engage with and benefit from the insights and guidance offered by Jyotish.
Distinguishing Between Inclusion & Cultural Appropriation
The globalization of Jyotish and its adoption by Western practitioners has introduced the peril of cultural appropriation, further exacerbating the existing patriarchal and hierarchical structures within the tradition. While it is crucial to address the exclusion of women from the Jyotish profession, it is equally imperative to differentiate between empowering women and perpetuating cultural appropriation.
In the past decade, cultural appropriation in the realm of Jyotish has been exemplified by fake practitioners who have erroneously adopted the tropical zodiac instead of the traditional sidereal zodiac, thereby distorting the authentic cultural and mythological significance inherent in Jyotish. This misappropriation misaligns the myths with the nakshatras, disrupting the age-old tradition of Vedic astrology and leading to a dilution of its cultural and spiritual essence. This misrepresentation not only misleads those seeking genuine insight and guidance but also disrespects the rich cultural heritage from which Jyotish stems. It is essential to acknowledge and preserve the authentic traditions of Jyotish, rooted in the sidereal zodiac, in order to honor its cultural significance and provide clients with accurate and meaningful interpretations.
True inclusivity in Jyotish entails recognizing the cultural significance and historical roots of the tradition, while also providing space for diverse voices and perspectives, including those of women. It involves amplifying the voices of traditional practitioners and incorporating their perspectives into the global practice of Jyotish. Moreover, it entails acknowledging and compensating the sources of knowledge and wisdom that have historically been marginalized or exploited. By distinguishing between genuine inclusion and cultural appropriation, the Jyotish community in the West can work towards a more respectful and equitable engagement with the tradition.
The “Cosmic Con Artist”
The phenomenon I refer to as the “Cosmic Con Artist” is indeed a troubling aspect within the realm of Vedic astrology, particularly in the West. Some self-proclaimed Vedic astrologers misuse Jyotish, employing it in dubious practices such as predicting stock market trends or cryptocurrency fluctuations. This not only misrepresents the true purpose and capabilities of Jyotish but also perpetuates a misguided and harmful perception of this ancient tradition. It’s essential to recognize that Jyotish is deeply rooted in a holistic and reverential understanding of the universe, emphasizing the interconnectedness of all things. When practitioners seek to exploit it for financial gain or to make sensationalist predictions, they not only disserve the integrity of Jyotish but also risk misleading those who place their trust in its insights.
Furthermore, as Jyotish is intimately tied to Hindu cosmology and philosophy, its practice necessitates a profound respect for its cultural and spiritual underpinnings. Unfortunately, some individuals, including Vedic astrologers from India, may engage in cultural appropriation and misinformation for financial motives. It seems some of the worst cultural appropriationists come from the culture itself. This can involve misleading students and clients about certain aspects of Jyotish or Hinduism for personal gain, distorting the authenticity and reverence of these traditions. Such behavior not only disrespects the rich cultural heritage from which Jyotish emanates but also perpetuates harmful stereotypes and misunderstandings. In essence, the misuse and exploitation of Jyotish for personal or financial gain not only undermine the integrity of this ancient tradition but also erode the trust and understanding of those who seek its guidance. It’s imperative for practitioners and seekers of Jyotish to approach its study and application with humility, responsibility, and a genuine commitment to honoring its roots and spiritual significance.
Remediation
One way to address the appropriation of Jyotish in the West while respecting its cultural significance is to ensure that training and education about Jyotish are conducted by authentic practitioners who understand and respect its cultural and traditional roots. This may involve collaboration with Indian scholars and practitioners to provide accurate and culturally sensitive teachings. Additionally, emphasizing the importance of understanding the philosophical and spiritual aspects of Jyotish can help practitioners in the West stay true to its essence, while avoiding superficial or exploitative practices. It’s important to approach the study of Jyotish with humility, recognizing the depth of its cultural and spiritual significance, and avoiding commercialization or commodification that may diminish its authenticity. Lastly, promoting cross-cultural dialogue and understanding can help to bridge the gap between Western interest in Jyotish and its traditional roots, fostering a more respectful and authentic approach to its practice.
Incorporating women as Jyotishis is not a form of cultural appropriation; rather, it is an important step in promoting gender equality and diversity within the practice of Jyotish. Encouraging and supporting female practitioners to study and practice Jyotish can help bring new perspectives and insights to the field, enriching the overall understanding and application of this ancient knowledge. One way to achieve this is by creating inclusive educational opportunities for women to learn Jyotish from authentic sources and supporting their professional growth within the field. Providing mentorship and guidance from experienced female Jyotishis can also help to empower and inspire the next generation of practitioners. Additionally, emphasizing the value of diverse voices and experiences within the Jyotish community can help to create a more inclusive and equitable environment for all practitioners. By actively supporting the inclusion of women in Jyotish, we can honor the tradition while fostering a more diverse and enriched practice.
The Future of Vedic Astrology
The future of Jyotish, like many traditional practices, is likely to be shaped by an ongoing dialogue between preserving its foundational principles and adapting to contemporary contexts. As society continues to evolve, there’s a growing recognition of the need to respect and honor the cultural origins of practices like Jyotish, while also addressing issues of cultural appropriation and inauthentic use. In this regard, the future of Jyotish may involve efforts to reclaim and elevate its authentic traditions, ensuring that its teachings are accurately represented and shared in ways that uphold their integrity.
Moreover, the evolving landscape of gender roles and perspectives on inclusivity is likely to influence the practice and accessibility of Jyotish. There is potential for a more inclusive and egalitarian interpretation of Jyotish, where gender considerations and diverse perspectives are honored, and in doing so, the practice could evolve to be more representative and supportive of a wider range of individuals.
In terms of innovation, the integration of Jyotish with modern technological advancements and scientific understanding may provide new avenues for its application and interpretation. This could lead to a deeper appreciation of Jyotish’s insights and principles, while also fostering a greater understanding of its underlying cosmological and metaphysical foundations.
Ultimately, the future of Jyotish is likely to be a balancing act between embracing innovation and preserving its cultural and spiritual essence. It may involve a continued effort to address concerns of cultural appropriation and misinformation, while also finding ways to adapt to the changing needs and perspectives of contemporary society. Through this ongoing dialogue and evolution, Jyotish has the potential to maintain its relevance and significance in the modern world while staying true to its authentic roots.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this ethnographic exploration of the contemporary state of Jyotish underscores the enduring impact of patriarchal and hierarchical structures within the astrological community. The observations reveal that the old patriarchal approach and the influence of the caste system continue to impede the diversification and evolution of Jyotish, depriving the profession of inclusive voices and hindering the empowerment of aspiring astrologers, particularly women. Addressing these systemic issues is crucial for the transformation of the Jyotish community into a more inclusive and empowering space. Efforts to dismantle the patriarchal and hierarchical barriers must be made to enable the flourishing of Jyotish as a progressive and equitable practice, and to ensure that all individuals, regardless of gender or background, have the opportunity to pursue and thrive in the field of Vedic astrology.
The discussion around Jyotish reflects the complex interplay between tradition, innovation, cultural appropriation, and inclusivity. As this ancient Vedic practice continues to navigate the modern world, the need to honor its cultural origins, address issues of appropriation, and adapt to contemporary contexts is paramount. The future of Jyotish lies in finding a delicate balance between preserving its foundational principles and embracing inclusivity, offering potential for greater representation and relevance in a rapidly changing world. By fostering an ongoing dialogue and evolution, Jyotish has the opportunity to maintain its authenticity while adapting to the needs and perspectives of diverse individuals and cultures.
References
1. Campion, Nicholas. “Astrology: The Celestial Mirror.” In Astrology and Cosmology in the Worlds Religions, 11–23. NYU Press, 2012. http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt9qg5q5.5.
2. Chakravarti, Uma. “Conceptualizing Brahmanical Patriarchy in early India: Gender, caste, class and state.” Economic and Political Weekly (1984): 11-21.
3. Chandra, Satish. “Religion and State in India and Search for Rationality.” Social Scientist 30, no. 3/4 (2002): 78–84. https://doi.org/10.2307/3518078.
4. Faris, Katya, MA. “Orientalism in Vedic Astrology.” https://hindustanastrology.com/jyotisha-blog/f/orientalism-and-vedic-astrology. 2018.
5. FRØYSTAD, KATHINKA. “The Return Path: Anthropology of a Western Yogi.” In Transnational Transcendence: Essays on Religion and Globalization, edited by Thomas J. Csordas, 1st ed., 279–304. University of California Press, 2009. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv11hprt5.15.
6. Lucia, Amanda J. “A Darshan Embrace: Experiencing Authenticity and Feeling Witnessed.” In Reflections of Amma: Devotees in a Global Embrace, 1st ed., 37–75. University of California Press, 2014. http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1525/j.ctt5hjh6k.7.
7. Menon, Ritu, and Kamla Bhasin. Borders and Boundaries: Women in India’s Partition. Rutgers University Press, 1998.
8. Norelli-Bachelet, Patrizia. “Caste, Culture And Cosmos.” World Affairs: The Journal of International Issues 6, no. 1 (2002): 120–38. http://www.jstor.org/stable/45064846.
9. Said, Edward. W. Orientalism. New York: Pantheon Books. (1978).
10. Sangari, Kumkum, and Sudesh Vaid. Recasting Women: Essays in Colonial History. Rutgers University Press, 1992.
11. Sen, Amartya. “Gender inequality and theories of justice.” Mcgill Law Journal 46.1 (2000): 253-276.
12. SEYMOUR, SUSAN C. “Sociocultural Change in India.” In Cora Du Bois: Anthropologist, Diplomat, Agent, 284–316. University of Nebraska Press, 2015. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctt1d9nj3b.16.
13. Sharabi, Asaf. “Local Traditions in Times of Change.” In The Biography of a God: Mahasu in the Himalayas, 117–56. Amsterdam University Press, 2023. https://doi.org/10.2307/jj.1614186.10.
14. Williamson, Lola. “Transcendental Meditation.” In Transcendent in America: Hindu-Inspired Meditation Movements as New Religion, 80–105. NYU Press, 2010. http://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt9qg57d.8.
